MetLife

Best pet insurance companies to compare in the U.S.

Start with ASPCA, Pets Best, and Trupanion for a dog or cat, then add a specialist pick if your situation calls for one. These are established, actively sold brands—not just names on a comparison site. There’s no universal cheapest or best policy: price and coverage depend on your pet and ZIP code. (consumerreports.org)

My practical recommendation: Get comparable accident-and-illness quotes from ASPCA, Pets Best, and Trupanion. Add MetLife for multiple pets, AKC for a pet with an existing condition, or Nationwide for an exotic pet. Use the same deductible, reimbursement percentage, and annual limit where possible. Before buying, read the exclusions and waiting periods—most policies do not cover pre-existing conditions, and most ordinarily reimburse you after you pay the vet. (content.naic.org)

Rankings differ by reviewer, but the same names keep showing up. These are the main ones, with what each is best known for.

Most frequently recommended

• Lemonade: ConsumerAffairs ranks it the top pet insurance company in 2026 based on customer satisfaction, claims handling, and customizable plans. CNBC picks it as best for dogs.
• Pumpkin: MoneyGeek calls it the best overall. Its digital tools can speed up claim reviews and give same-day reimbursements.
• Pets Best: Yahoo Finance ranks it best overall for its low average costs and ample coverage. Forbes names it the best cat insurance for its competitive prices and coverage options.
• ASPCA Pet Health Insurance: NerdWallet puts it first for comprehensive coverage. It also has accident-only plans and strong customization.
• Spot: Known for the best perks. Money.com singles it out for unlimited coverage.
• Embrace: Customizable plans. CNBC lists it as best for discounts, and Money.com lists it as best for military veterans.
• MetLife: A good fit for multi-pet households. It is also the only insurer offering exotic pet coverage among those Yahoo analyzed. Nationwide also covers exotic pets.
• Healthy Paws: Offers unlimited coverage with no per-incident limits.

Other names to know

• Figo is best for senior pets and has a 100% reimbursement option.
• Trupanion is known for paying the vet directly.
• Nationwide covers exotic pets.
• AKC is the pick for pre-existing conditions, per CNBC and Money.com.
• Liberty Mutual is the lowest-cost pick in Yahoo's ranking.

Quick picks

Tips

• Best-for-X lists often conflict, and some reviewers earn affiliate commissions. NerdWallet's advice is to get quotes from at least three companies.
• Price depends heavily on your pet's age, breed, and ZIP code.
• Check the waiting periods, the annual limit, the deductible, and the reimbursement percentage. Also ask about premium increases as your pet ages. Forbes' user feedback flags significant premium increases as a complaint about ASPCA.
• Enroll while your pet is young and healthy. Pre-existing conditions are generally excluded.

If you tell me your pet's species, age, breed, and budget, I can narrow this to two or three options.

When choosing pet insurance in the United States, the best option depends on your pet’s age, breed, health history, and your budget. Standard policies in the U.S. cover accidents and illnesses (diagnostics, surgery, emergency care, medications), while optional wellness riders cover routine care like vaccinations and annual checkups.

The top, most widely used pet insurance companies in the U.S., categorized by what they do best, include:

1. Lemonade – Best Overall Value & Digital Experience

• Why people use it: Lemonade offers some of the lowest baseline monthly rates for cats and dogs, coupled with an easy-to-use mobile app. Claims are often processed instantly through their AI engine.
• Highlights:
  • Highly customizable plans (70%–90% reimbursement, flexible deductibles).
  • Add-on options for physical therapy, vet visit fees, dental illness, and preventative care.
  • Multi-policy discounts if you bundle with Lemonade renters or home insurance.
• Best for: Tech-savvy owners looking for affordable, baseline coverage for young, healthy dogs and cats.

2. Pets Best – Best Budget Choice & Low Deductibles

• Why people use it: Pets Best consistently ranks among the most affordable providers, especially for cats. They offer high flexibility with deductibles starting as low as $50.
• Highlights:
  • Option for direct payment to vets so you don't have to pay out-of-pocket for large emergency bills.
  • Unlimited coverage limits available.
  • No upper age limits for enrolling senior pets.
• Best for: Budget-conscious pet parents and owners of senior pets.

3. Spot – Best for Customization & Multi-Pet Households

• Why people use it: Spot offers extensive customization options for coverage limits (from $2,500 up to Unlimited) and deductible choices.
• Highlights:
  • Generous 10% multi-pet discount.
  • Covers microchipping, behavioral issues, and alternative therapies in basic accident & illness plans.
  • 24/7 telehealth access via a vet helpline.
• Best for: Families with multiple pets or owners wanting tailor-made coverage caps.

4. Trupanion – Best for Direct Vet Payment & Chronic Conditions

• Why people use it: Trupanion uses software installed directly at thousands of U.S. veterinary hospitals to pay the vet at the time of checkout, meaning you only pay your portion (e.g., 10%) on the spot.
• Highlights:
  • Per-condition lifetime deductible: You pay a deductible once per illness or injury for your pet’s entire life, rather than resetting an annual deductible every year.
  • Flat 90% reimbursement rate with no annual or lifetime payout limits.
• Best for: Pets predisposed to lifelong chronic conditions (like diabetes, allergies, or hip dysplasia) and owners who want to avoid high out-of-pocket expenses upfront.

5. Embrace – Best for Comprehensive Coverage & Diminishing Deductibles

• Why people use it: Embrace is known for broad coverage and its unique "Healthy Pet Deductible" feature, which reduces your annual deductible by $50 for every year you don't file a claim.
• Highlights:
  • Covers alternative treatments (acupressure, hydrotherapy, chiropractic care) and behavioral care.
  • Flex Care wellness rewards program for routine vet bills.
  • Short 2-day waiting period for accidents.
• Best for: Complete illness and accident coverage with long-term policy rewards.

6. ASPCA Pet Health Insurance – Best All-Inclusive Baseline Coverage

• Why people use it: Managed by PTZ Insurance, ASPCA Pet Health includes coverage in its standard plans for things many other providers charge extra for (such as microchipping, behavioral therapy, dental illness, and alternative care).
• Highlights:
  • No maximum age limit for enrolling pets.
  • 10% multi-pet discount.
  • Offers specialized plans for horses alongside dogs and cats.
• Best for: Owners looking for a standard plan that automatically includes comprehensive holistic care.

7. Nationwide – Best for Exotic Pets & Corporate Benefits

• Why people use it: Nationwide is the only major U.S. insurer that covers exotic pets (birds, reptiles, rabbits, guinea pigs, etc.). They are also the most common provider offered as a voluntary benefit through corporate U.S. employers (often with employee discounts).
• Highlights:
  • WholePet plans offer broad coverage with fixed percentage payouts.
  • Seamless integration if offered via employer payroll deductions.
• Best for: Owners of non-traditional pets or employees eligible for workplace pet insurance discounts.

Key Things to Look Out For Before Buying:

1. Pre-Existing Conditions: No standard U.S. pet insurance covers pre-existing conditions (illnesses or injuries that occurred before coverage starts or during waiting periods). Enrolling pets while they are young and healthy is critical.
2. Reimbursement Structure: Most plans operate on a reimbursement model. You pay the vet bill out of pocket, upload your receipt, and the insurer sends a check or direct deposit for 70%, 80%, or 90% of the covered total. If paying upfront is a challenge, prioritize Pets Best or Trupanion for direct vet payments.
3. Annual vs. Lifetime Caps: Decide if you want a fixed annual limit (e.g., $5,000 or $10,000/year) to save on monthly premiums, or an Unlimited cap for peace of mind in high-cost emergency care scenarios.

Quick Summary Recommendation:

• Best Budget: Lemonade or Pets Best
• Best Pay-at-Checkout: Trupanion
• Best for Multi-Pet: Spot or Embrace
• Best for Exotic Animals: Nationwide

The strongest U.S. pet-insurance brands to compare are Lemonade, Pets Best, Pumpkin, Spot, ASPCA Pet Health Insurance, Embrace, Healthy Paws, Fetch, Figo, MetLife, and Trupanion. No single company is best for every pet: premiums and coverage vary substantially by species, breed, age, location, deductible, reimbursement rate, and annual limit.

Best choices by need

Practical recommendations

• Best starting shortlist for most dog owners: Lemonade, Pets Best, Embrace, Pumpkin, and ASPCA.
• Best starting shortlist for most cat owners: Pets Best, Lemonade, Embrace, Healthy Paws, and Pumpkin.
• For a senior pet: Compare Spot, Figo, and ASPCA first, but check exclusions and the pet’s age eligibility carefully.
• For several pets: Compare Pumpkin, MetLife, and Pets Best, paying attention to whether discounts apply per pet or to the household.
• For expensive breeds or serious chronic-condition risk: Favor unlimited annual coverage, a high reimbursement percentage, and coverage for hereditary and congenital conditions.
• For the lowest premium: Consider a higher deductible, 70% reimbursement, and a lower annual limit—but confirm that the plan still covers exam fees, diagnostics, prescriptions, hereditary conditions, and dental illness.

What to check before buying

1. Pre-existing-condition rules: Virtually all major plans exclude conditions that showed signs before enrollment or during waiting periods.
2. Waiting periods: Compare accident, illness, orthopedic, and cruciate-ligament waiting periods separately.
3. Annual limits: Unlimited coverage costs more but reduces the risk of exhausting benefits after surgery or cancer treatment.
4. Reimbursement method: Some plans reimburse a percentage after the deductible; others use benefit schedules or per-condition limits.
5. Exam-fee coverage: A plan may cover treatment while excluding the veterinary examination fee.
6. Dental coverage: Check whether it covers dental illness, not merely accidental tooth damage.
7. Premium increases: Rates can rise as pets age and after regional veterinary-cost changes; Consumer Reports found overall satisfaction across the market only middling, so claims experience and price deserve equal attention.
8. Renewal and bilateral-condition exclusions: These can matter for knee, hip, eye, and ear problems affecting both sides of the body.

A sensible buying process is to obtain quotes from at least three companies using identical settings—same deductible, reimbursement percentage, and annual limit—then compare the policy documents rather than relying only on the monthly premium. NerdWallet also recommends getting at least three quotes because the best value depends on the pet and coverage needs.

No single pet insurer is “best” for everyone—premiums and coverage vary a lot by ZIP code, pet age/breed, deductible, reimbursement rate, and annual limit. But if you want the brands people in the U.S. actually quote and use most, these are the ones I’d shortlist:

Top commonly used / recommended U.S. pet insurers

If most people just want a practical shortlist

Get quotes from these 4–6:

1. Trupanion — if you want strong major-medical coverage and possible direct vet pay.
2. Healthy Paws — if you want simple unlimited accident/illness coverage.
3. Pets Best — if you want customizable coverage at a competitive price.
4. Embrace — if you want a diminishing deductible or wellness add-on.
5. Lemonade — if you want the easiest app/claims experience.
6. Nationwide — if you have an employer/affinity discount or want a very established brand.

What to compare before buying

• Reimbursement rate: 70%, 80%, or 90%
• Annual deductible: lower deductible = higher premium
• Annual payout limit: unlimited is best for major illness
• Pre-existing conditions: almost never covered
• Hereditary/congenital conditions: make sure they’re covered
• Exam fees: often excluded unless added
• Dental illness: often limited or excluded
• Waiting periods: typically 14 days for illness, shorter for accidents
• Bilateral conditions: e.g., cruciate ligament—one side may affect coverage for the other
• Premium increases: ask how often rates rise with age

Bottom line: For most U.S. pet owners, the strongest commonly used shortlist is Trupanion, Healthy Paws, Pets Best, Embrace, Nationwide, Lemonade, and Fetch. Quote several with the same deductible/reimbursement/limit so you’re comparing apples to apples.

There is no single "best" pet insurance company in the US—it depends on your pet’s age, breed, health history, your budget, and priorities like low premiums, unlimited coverage, direct vet payments, or extras such as dental/behavioral coverage.

The strongest options combine competitive pricing, solid reimbursement (typically 70-90%, sometimes up to 100%), customizable deductibles/annual limits, reasonable waiting periods (often 0-15 days for accidents, 14 days for illnesses), and positive customer feedback on claims. Always get personalized quotes, as rates vary widely by location, pet details, and chosen coverage. Review policy details for pre-existing condition exclusions (standard across the industry) and any breed/age restrictions.

Top Highly Rated Brands (Based on Recent Expert Reviews)

These frequently appear at or near the top of 2025-2026 comparisons from sites like NerdWallet, Bankrate, Forbes Advisor, U.S. News, Consumer Reports, and others for coverage, value, claims experience, and features:

• Lemonade — Often the most affordable with fast (sometimes AI-assisted) claims processing. Good for budget-conscious owners; solid basic accident/illness coverage with wellness add-ons available. Sample averages around $38–$46/month for dogs and lower for cats in recent analyses. Strong for value and speed.

• ASPCA Pet Health Insurance — Frequently ranked best overall for comprehensive coverage, including strong customer service and options like direct vet pay in some cases. Reliable across many reviews; sample rates around $39–$46/month for dogs.

• Spot — Praised for perks, customization, and broad coverage (including behavioral therapy or alternative treatments in some plans). Competitive rates and unlimited options available.

• Pets Best — Strong value with low-to-moderate average premiums (around $40/month for dogs in some studies), customizable plans, and options for direct vet payments. Good for flexibility.

• Figo — Competitive pricing (often among the lowest averages, e.g., ~$38/month dogs), high reimbursement options (up to 100%), and quick accident coverage start in some cases.

• Pumpkin — Excellent for comprehensive plans that cover extras like dental illness, behavioral issues, and alternative therapies. Fast claims noted in reviews; good for thorough coverage even if premiums are higher.

• Embrace — Stands out for features like a diminishing deductible (reduces over time with claim-free years) and solid hereditary/illness coverage.

• MetLife — Useful for multi-pet households (shared deductibles/limits in some plans) and quick accident coverage start. Customizable with wellness options.

Other notables include Trupanion (unlimited coverage, 90% reimbursement, direct vet payments via its network—popular for chronic conditions but often pricier with per-condition deductibles) and Healthy Paws (unlimited plans, strong satisfaction scores).

What People Actually Use (Market Share/Popularity)

Larger established players dominate by premiums written:

• Trupanion leads with the highest market share (~29-30% in recent data) and is a top underwriter.
• Nationwide follows closely (significant share, around 19-21%), known for broad availability including exotics in some plans.
• Growing digital/direct-to-consumer options like Lemonade, Spot, Pumpkin, Embrace, and Fetch (formerly Petplan) are increasingly popular among newer policyholders for ease of use and modern features. JAB Holdings-affiliated brands have shown strong growth.

Consumer Reports surveys indicate most policyholders find pet insurance worthwhile overall, though satisfaction with specific aspects (like claims or service) varies and is generally moderate across providers.

Quick Tips for Choosing and Buying

• Compare quotes from at least 3–5 providers (many offer instant online quotes).
• Prioritize: Unlimited or high annual limits for serious conditions; 80-90%+ reimbursement; low deductibles if your pet has health risks; wellness riders for routine care if desired.
• Check waiting periods, orthopedic/knee exclusions (common), and renewal stability (premiums often rise with age).
• Availability is nationwide for most, but confirm your state.
• Read recent policy documents, as terms can change.

For the most current fit, visit provider sites or comparison tools and factor in your specific situation. Independent reviews are helpful, but personalized quotes are essential.

The top pet insurance companies people actually use—based on U.S. News, NerdWallet, and Forbes—are Lemonade, ASPCA, Spot, Pets Best, Pumpkin, MetLife, Fetch, Embrace, Healthy Paws, and Prudent Pet, each excelling in different needs.

⭐ Quick Take: The Most Trusted Brands

These companies consistently appear across multiple independent rankings:

Lemonade — Best overall value and lowest premiums ASPCA — Most comprehensive coverage and best overall per NerdWallet Spot — Best perks and broad coverage Pets Best — Best budget option and lowest sample premiums Pumpkin — Highest customer satisfaction and fastest payouts MetLife — Best for multi‑pet households and shortest accident waiting period Fetch — Best dental and wellness coverage Embrace — Great for 24/7 vet help and flexible wellness options Healthy Paws — Best unlimited lifetime payouts and simple coverage Prudent Pet — Forbes’ top overall plan for price + coverage

🐾 What Each Company Is Best At

Lemonade — Best overall; lowest premiums; strong customer satisfaction; many optional add‑ons. ASPCA — Best comprehensive coverage; covers horses; broad standard benefits; top NerdWallet score. Spot — Best perks; 24/7 vet helpline; fast claim reimbursement; strong coverage for behavioral and alternative therapies. Pets Best — Best budget; lowest monthly rates; direct vet pay option; customizable tiers. Pumpkin — Best customer satisfaction; urgent pay service for emergencies; strong wellness options. MetLife — Best for multiple pets; shared deductibles; zero‑day accident waiting period. Fetch — Best dental coverage; covers every tooth and advanced treatments. Embrace — Best 24/7 vet support; flexible wellness tiers; long claim‑filing window. Healthy Paws — Best unlimited coverage; fast claim settlement; simple plan structure. Prudent Pet — Best overall per Forbes; competitive pricing and strong satisfaction.

📊 Comparison Table: Top Choices by Need

Company | Best For | Key Strengths | Source Lemonade | Overall value | Lowest premiums, many add‑ons | U.S. News 1, Forbes 1 ASPCA | Comprehensive coverage | Covers most conditions; includes horses | NerdWallet 1 Spot | Perks | 24/7 helpline, fast claims | NerdWallet 1, Forbes 1 Pets Best | Budget | Lowest sample premiums; direct vet pay | U.S. News 1, Forbes 1 Pumpkin | Customer satisfaction | Fast payouts; strong wellness | U.S. News 1, NerdWallet 1 MetLife | Multi‑pet | Shared deductibles; zero‑day accident waiting | U.S. News 1, NerdWallet 1 Fetch | Dental | Covers all teeth + advanced dental | Forbes 1 Embrace | 24/7 vet help | Phone/video/chat support | Forbes 1 Healthy Paws | Unlimited payouts | Cheapest unlimited coverage | U.S. News 1, Forbes 1 Prudent Pet | Best overall (Forbes) | Strong price + coverage | Forbes 1 3 Sources3

✅ How to Choose

Pick based on your priority:

Lowest cost: Pets Best or Lemonade Most coverage: ASPCA or Spot Fast payouts: Pumpkin Senior pets: Spot or ASPCA Multiple pets: MetLife Dental needs: Fetch Simple unlimited plan: Healthy Paws

If you want, I can help you choose based on your pet’s age, breed, and budget.

Top pet insurance companies in the United States stand out for their coverage options, customer satisfaction, and popularity among pet owners.

Top Pet Insurance Companies & Brands

Pets Best: Frequently ranked among the top overall providers by industry analysts (such as U.S. News & World Report), offering customizable accident and illness coverage options. Lemonade: Popular for its fast, mobile-first claims process and generally competitive pricing for younger pets. Trupanion: Widely recognized because many veterinary clinics can pay Trupanion directly at checkout rather than requiring owners to wait for reimbursement; known for direct-to-vet payment options and high payout caps. Fetch (formerly Fetch by The Dodo): Noted for strong comprehensive coverage, including dental disease support and sick-visit exam fees. Embrace: Praised for features like 24/7 pet help lines and vanishing deductibles for healthy years. Spot: Offers plans with no upper age limit for enrollment, options for custom coverage levels, and multi-pet discounts. ASPCA Pet Health Insurance: Well-regarded for multi-pet households and straightforward wellness add-ons.

What Real Pet Owners Say

Experiences vary widely depending on claim histories, pricing adjustments, and whether pre-existing conditions are involved.

Pet owners frequently discuss the trade-offs between monthly premiums, claim processing speeds, and coverage exclusions across popular communities. “ Heathy paws 69, MetLife Pet 63, Pets best 87, Nationwide??? Lemonade pet insurance 88, Spot pet insurance - through Sam's Club 53, Trupanion - most vets deal with 117, Figo - through Costco 97, Fetch 95, Embrace 56, Pumpkin 50-116, Odie 39 ” Facebook · What's Happening in Port Orange “ Prudent Pet: For $38.29/mth, we are covered at 80% with a $500 deductible for accidents, injuries, and illness as well as all Veterinarian Exams. ” Facebook · Ask the Hat “ There's no single ‘best’ pet insurance for everyone. The right plan depends on your pet's age, breed, health, budget, and the coverage you need. ” Facebook · Pawlicy Advisor

How to Choose

Because insurance costs and policy terms depend heavily on your pet's specifics, you can compare multi-insurer quotes side-by-side using comparison platforms like the Pawlicy Advisor Marketplace or check independent evaluations via the Consumer Reports Pet Insurance Guide.

If you'd like a more tailored recommendation, tell me:Your pet's species and breed (dog, cat, or specific mix) Your pet's age Whether you are looking strictly for accidents/illnesses or also want routine/wellness care I can help narrow down which brands fit your goals.

When looking at the top-rated and most widely used pet insurance brands in the United States, several standout companies consistently lead the market for coverage, customer satisfaction, and practical utility.

Review the top brands that real pet parents use, organized by what they do best:

1. ASPCA Pet Insurance

Best For: Overall comprehensive coverage and peace of mind. Why people use it: Backed by a premier name in animal welfare, it offers robust standard policies that include coverage for behavioral issues, alternative therapies, and congenital conditions without an upper age limit for enrollment. The details: Features customizable annual maximums, deductibles, and reimbursement rates (typically 70%-90%). You can check plans and details directly via ASPCA Pet Insurance. ASPCA Pet Insurance

2. Spot Pet Insurance

Best For: Customizable plans and great extra perks. Why people use it: Spot is heavily favored by owners who want to tailor their deductibles and annual limits tightly to their budget. They also include great optional wellness add-ons for routine care like dental cleanings and vaccinations. The details: Excellent digital account management and quick add-on selections. Explore options on Spot Pet Insurance. Spot Pet Insurance

3. MetLife Pet Insurance

Best For: Multi-pet households and employer benefits. Why people use it: MetLife has grown massively in popularity, especially because many companies now offer it as a voluntary workplace benefit. It stands out for making it easy to insure multiple pets under flexible family plans, often with no breed exclusions or upper age limits. The details: Immediate accident coverage is available in many policies, alongside 24/7 virtual vet chat access. Learn more at MetLife Pet Insurance. MetLife Pet Insurance

4. Pumpkin Pet Insurance

Best For: Fast claim processing and high reimbursement. Why people use it: Pumpkin is a favorite for owners who hate waiting weeks for reimbursements. They offer expedited direct payouts and include coverage for exam fees standard in their core illness/accident plans (which many competitors charge extra for). The details: High acceptance rates and robust coverage for things like prescription food and physical therapy. Look into policies at Pumpkin Pet Insurance. Pumpkin Pet Insurance

5. Trupanion

Best For: Direct vet payment capabilities. Why people use it: Unlike most providers where you pay the vet bill out-of-pocket and wait for a reimbursement check, Trupanion's software allows them to pay participating vets directly at checkout. It is widely praised and trusted across the veterinary community. The details: Known for lifetime per-condition deductibles rather than annual ones. Read community reviews and specifics on Trupanion. Trupanion

If you'd like to narrow this down, tell me:

What is your pet's species, breed, and age? Are you looking strictly for accidents and illnesses, or do you want routine wellness care included?

I can help you figure out which of these brands will give you the best value for your specific situation.